9-1-1

9-1-1
9-1-1; What Is Your Emergency?

Saturday, May 10, 2014

More Than Just 9-1-1: Specialization in the Field of Public Safety Dispatching & Reliability

Taken from Public Safety Communications Magazine, September 2010
Written by Christopher Blake Carver, MPA - Mr. Carver has 17 years of experience in public safety communications.


Sometimes lost in the use of the term 9-1-1 dispatcher or communications technician is the reality that, within many agencies or communities, the role of a telecommunicator requires a significantly greater degree of specialization.  The degree may be based on workload, number of agencies dispatched for, telecommunicator skills and other operational realities.  These specializations, although essential, contribute to the complexity of the job of a telecommunicator and serve to highlight the often opposing skill sets they require.

This summary of these specializations is intended to serve as a guide for those new to the field or those who may be involved with communications from a consulting or political prospective, without a thorough, on-the-platform knowledge of what makes up a telecommunicator's daily workload.  For the communications manager or supervisor, this list is intended to identify possible ways to improve workflow and agency affectiveness -- especially during times of heightened activity.

BY GEOGRAPHIC AREA
One of the first areas in which specialization occurs for telecommunicators is by area the telecommunicator is responsible for.  In many cases, a dispatcher may be hired by one town and dispatch all of the agencies in that one community (police, fire, EMS).  These single-dispatcher environments remain a relatively common occurrence in the U.S.

Specialization by geographic area may also occur in a larger center, in which one telecommuicator may be assigned to cover services for one particular area on a regular basis for a special-event-related geographic area for a shorter duration.  Many new CAD systems also allow the user to create temporary areas for dispatching, such as an area affected by a storm.

There are many positives to this approach -- especially if all the responders have interoperable radios, can use compatible radio procedures and are empowered to share information.  Having a single dispatcher (or single dispatch group) manage a disaster-stricken area will ensure effective sharing of information and improve the effectiveness of the response.

BY AGENCY
The second tier of specialization is in assigning telecommunicators to be responsible for certain agencies -- and this is often the first level of growth in public safety communications centers.  Having one telecommunicator dedicated to fire/EMS and another to the police function is a logical step in workload management.  At this point, it's also required to point out that this is the first point of identification of the different skill-sets required to dispatch fire/EMS apparatus vs. dispatching police units.  Training for telecommunicators should acknowledge these differences in approach and ensure that telecommunicators who will be undertaking both roles are aware of and able to adjust to both sides of the floor.

BY ROLES & RESPONSIBILITIES
Given the distinct differences in fire/EMS and police dispatching, the functions by role are also related to the overall agency function that a given telecommunicator is assigned to.  Based on the size of population served, agency policies and preference, and workload, the functions of telecommunicators in the communications center may be organized along what role they are playing in the dispatching flow-chart.  It should be noted that one telecommunicator may serve the same role for different agencies in the center (i.e., there may be one records dispatcher for multiple agency radio dispatchers or one fire-ground dispatcher for the various primary fire/EMS agencies that are dispatched in one center).  It may also be possible for one telecommunicator to handle specific roles during non-peak periods of activity and that roles by expanded during periods of high activity.  During a storm, for example all of the roles may be filled by specific telecommunicators, while at 3 a.m., one telecommunicator may have two or three roles.

In most cases, however, telecommunicators should not be responsible for handling more than one or two channels at the same time -- and only more than one channel or talk group if the channels are not that active and the dispatcher isn't busy with other tasks or responsibilities.  Expecting one tactical dispatcher to monitor two or three fireground channels is a potentially very unsafe practice and could result in degraded fireground or incident safety -- particularly if your agency requires the dispatcher to monitor every fireground transmission.  A good rule of thumb is to limit the number of potential channels or talk groups that units can operate on to the total number of dispatchers on shift in the communications center.

ROLES FOR FIRE/EMS DISPATCHING
  • 9-1-1/phone answering and alarm processing -- Self-explanatory, but needs to be identified, especially if your agency provides emergency medical dispatch and associated pre-arrival instructions
  • Incident assignment/response coverage -- Fire/EMS dispatchers (often separate from calltakers) are responsible for ensuring the appropriate response is sent to incidents and adequate fire protection is maintained in the event of a serious incident or period of high activity.
  • Dispatch/communications with units out of quarters -- One dispatcher will need to be available to communicate with units that are not in quarters to not only ensure they are responding to calls, but also to respond to messages from those units, such as changes in status, reports of emergencies they witness or other messages.
  • Dispatch to in-quarters units/firehouse alerting -- Although this process can often be automated with such products as Locution, in many agencies alerting to firehouse PAs or intercoms remains a dispatcher function.
  • Notifications dispatcher -- Many incidents will result in units on scene requesting the response of another agency (e.g., electric company, gas company, police) or notification to a hospital, such as with a cardiac arrest patient.
  • Incident dispatcher -- In departments where dispatcher are required to monitor fireground communications to receive requests and information from the incident commander and to relay messages from the communications center to the scene, this is a critical function that requires a dedicated dispatcher.  Often, these dispatchers are an essential element of safety on the fire or emergency scene - monitoring for emergency buttons being depressed (the ID of the potentially in-trouble unit is displayed on most modern radio consoles) - and ensuring timely reports on member accountability (PAR).  Incident dispatchers also enter in narrative descriptions of the event, acess building information from available sources and confer with the incident assignment dispatcher should additional resources be required.
ROLES IN POLICE DISPATCHING
  • Calltaking dispatcher -- Often, the 9-1-1 element of the communications center and in many agencies the same calltaker for police, fire and EMS incidents.
  • Assignment/radio dispatcher -- Most agencies are divided into geographic areas, where one dispatcher serves as the radio and assignment dispatcher for the given area.
  • Records/leads dispatcher -- Many larger agencies utilize a separate channel and dedicated dispatcher to handle more involved requests for criminal records checks, report numbers or other functions that would overload the main dispatch channel if done there.
  • Tow dispatcher -- Some very large agencies have dedicated dispatchers to manage requests for tow trucks and/or other outside agencies.
  • "Back-channel" dispatcher -- Some larger police agencies staff an extra dispatcher on a non-primary channel to manage other requests, handle tactical incidents or other functions, such as special events.
CONCLUSIONS
Understanding  the manner in which job functions in the 9-1-1 center can be organized facilitates not only a greater understanding of the complexity of the role of the public safety communications professional, but also serves as a potential roadmap to the operational and training needs inherent in the operation of 9-1-1 centers.  Regardless of the size of a 9-1-1 center -- or the number of agencies served, these basic roles and functions are what telecommunicators across the U.S. do every day -- whether they are alone in a small town police department radio room -- or sharing those functions with hundreds of other telecommunicators in a footfall field size 9-1-1 center in a major American city.

Using these understandings to develop a scalable model based on workload, agency requirements, staffing and other factors permits local community leaders and 9-1-1 managers to ensure that their 9-1-1 center meets the demands of its customers both on normal days and during peak periods.  Fortunately, new CAD systems and modern radio systems support these types of configurations, as well as allowing certain processes -- such as notifications and firehouse alerting -- to be automated, freeing up personnel to perform the valuable tasks of incident monitoring, ensuring effective response coverage and further improving the ability of communications centers and their personnel to perform the essential parts of their jobs that are beyond 9-1-1.

From The Editor's Desk

Taken from Dispatch Monthly Magazine, Volume 20.5
Written by Gary Allen, Editor of Dispatch Monthly Magazine


You may recall the "good old days" when communications centers had the luxury of simply answering the telephone and radioing information to field units.  Then along came cellular phones, and it hasn't been the same since.  The public safety communications industry has been on a faster and faster treadmill, trying to catch up with all the technology being invented.  It hasn't been easy.

Before the nation's comm centers could equip themselves with Phase II gear for cellular 911, along comes VoIP telephony.  And then New York City's mayor Bloomberg announced he wants a 911 system capable of handling text, photos and video.

I'm certainly happy that APCO and NENA are tackling the high-level, legislative and funding issues related to rolling out all this technology.  There's enough Washington (DC) activity to keep both organizations busy every day.  But back home, where the 911 calls are being answered, there is still work to be done.

Lately, the news is swarming with stories from all points of the country about delayed response times, missed incidents and other human errors leading to injury and death.  Perhaps it's just the law of averages that these incidents are appearing now.  But it certainly deserves a look.

The challenge of a comm center, after hiring the right people and training them adequately, is to establish a set of procedures and policies that maximize the public's safety.  First, you must recognize those situations that require a procedure and policy, so that when it occurs the dispatchers will handle it as the agency requires.  Second, within each situation you must recognize every possibility, so that no odd occurence will not be handled ad hoc.  Lastly, you must be supervising and auditing the performance of the dispatchers to insure that all of procedures and policies are being followed.

Several recent incidents seem to be focused on the very narrow portion of dispatching related to a dispatcher's discretion when handling telephone calls: the calltaker decides that the call was made accidentally, that the caller doesn't have an emergency, and then doesn't send anyone to investigate.  Many of these calls were made from cellular phones.  These situations should be an area of particular focus for managers and directors to insure the center's procedures provide enough guidance for their employees to successfully handle these types of calls.

I look forward to seeing negative stories disappear from the news radar screens, and to the resulting lawsuits.  But it's going to take some work at individual centers before that will happen.

Friday, May 9, 2014

9-1-1: Making a Difference

Taken from Public Safety Communications Magazine, August 2010, APCO Bulletin > Association News & Notes > Standards


The public safety communications community makes a difference every day.  We answer calls from people who need assistance, and we give support and provide information to protect the responders providing that help.  9-1-1 makes a difference every hour of every day.  Public safety communications professionals, at all levels and assignments, follow procedures on a daily basis to perform our duties.  How are those procedures developed?  They are developed by individuals, like you, who perform the duties or have knowledge and experience in the community.  One method is to develop consensus standards, but to get consensus standards, a balanced group of people need to provide that consensus.

APCO Standards Committee:  APCO has taken a lead in the public safety communications community by becoming an American National Standards Institute (ANSI)-Accredited Standards Developer (ASD).  The APCO Standards Development Committee's (SDC) scope is: APCO International will serve as a conduit to develop standards that will focus on public safety communications, including, but not limited to, training and professional development, professional qualifications, education, performance programs, technology, systems, operations and other related issues.

The SDC has three subcommittees that focus on specific areas:
  • Training, which develops training and competencies standards;
  • Operations, which develops operational standards; and
  • Technical, which develops technical and equipment standards.
The SDC and its subcommittees have three member categories:
  • Producer (i.e., a producer of public safety communications equipment, products, processes, systems or services);
  • User (i.e., those who use public safety communications equipment, products, processes, systems or services); and
  • General interest (i.e., all others, including, but not limited to, professional associations and societies and regulatory agencies).
What can you do?  Participate; join a committee.  One great way to get involved is to help develop and approve standards.  The SDC is currently expanding and looking for members to help facilitate important standards for the public safety communications community.  A diverse knowledge base and individual experience benefits standards by addressing the needs of and providing insight from all stakeholders.  Your input in developing and reviewing candidate standards can prove invaluable regardless of your background.  This participation allows you to be proactive.  Not only will you understand what standards are being developed, but you will have input into the changes in the industry.

To participate in APCO Standards activities, go to www.apcostandards.org or e-mail standards@apcointl.org for more information.  Members are selected from applications based on the positions open and the applicant's background to ensure balance and lack of dominance.  There are opportunities to join SDC committees and provide subject matter expertise.

Call to action: If you can't join the committee, you can still participate.  As new standards are prepared, the candidates are announced in a Call to Action.  These are for proposals for APCO standards and standards from other organizations that may affect the public safety community.  When these notices are published, look into the standards that affect you and provide feedback.  This feedback can be potential changes or a different way to accomplish the same actions.  It can be as simple as a comment that the proposed standard is a good solution to its issue.

Learn, act and connect with your leaders.  We need your help to develop and approve standards that enhance public safety communications.

~ QUESTIONS? E-mail standards@apcointl.org.

Challenges of Mobile Alarm Devices

Taken from Public Safety Communications Magazine, August 2010
Written by Kathy McMahon, APCO Technical Services Manager


Devices designed to automatically signal for help have been available for years.  Many of them are programmed to dial a private call center or alarm company that in turn notifies the appropriate PSAP that emergency response is needed.  Some devices dial 9-1-1 directly.  But until recently, these auto-dial devices or alarms primarily reported only a fixed, registered location for the person needing assistance.

The increasing use of wireless phones and developing wireless technologies provide unique opportunities, allowing mobile alarm devices to automatically dial 9-1-1 when activated by a user or an authorized third party.  Prior to opening a voice connection to a caller, many of these devices provide the calltaker with a recorded message indicating a potential emergency.  Calltakers receiving these alarms are presented with an ANI/ALI screen  representative of the wireless Phase 1 or wireless Phase 2 call.  In some cases, direct contact with the individual in need is enabled, and the calltaker can ascertain incident details directly.  In other cases, calltakers receive a recorded message with instructions to contact a private call center for more details.

Applications are also being developed that will notify citizens if a device fixed to a person under their authority moves outside of a specific geographic zone and to enable a wireless device to call 9-1-1 in cases of the theft of high-risk cargo.

Developing applications that increase the probability that an endangered person or high-risk collateral can be found more quickly has the potential to positively affect public safety and decrease the time it takes to resolve such incidents.  However, the ability of PSAPs to effectively react to these notifications is still uncertain.  In cases in which direct contact is made with a victim and details of an emergency are obtained, the challenges are less.  Scenarios in which direct contact isn't possible make it more difficult for a calltaker to determine the best way to respond.  Open-line wireless calls aren't new to 9-1-1, but many have been attributed to accidental dialing.  If a PSAP can't confirm details from a wireless call's open line, the options for identifying and locating the caller are limited.

Implementing mobile alarm device technologies has the potential to significantly increase the number of calls in which PSAPs won't have direct contact with callers.  These challenges are coupled with the fact that wireless technologies don't offer pinpoint location accuracy for these devices.  The extended amount of time it takes to manage these calls can affect the PSAPs calltaking capability and answering time efficiency.

In addition, marketing for mobile alarm devices, if not executed carefully, could mislead customers into believing that help will be on the way once their device is activated -- even if they are unable to provide further details.  Technologies that require PSAPs to contact a third-party call center for more information require additional steps by the calltaker that may not result in determining the individual's exact location.  It's critical to couple the deployment of such technologies with a strategy to manage the public's expectations of how the technology benefits them.

Many years ago there was a commercial on TV that showed a group of children who were unsure about a new cereal.  Their answer to the problem: "Let's get Mikey.  He will eat it; he eats anything."  Unfortunately, Mikey doesn't work at 9-1-1.  PSAPs are still expected to incorporate these technologies into their operations even though they may be uncomfortable with them.  Vendors deploying new solutions, such as mobile alarm or alerting devices, are encouraged to work with associations, such as APCO, and local PSAPs to better understand how these 9-1-1 calls are handled and how their technology may affect comm center.

Thursday, May 8, 2014

'Had This Been a Real Emergency....' Disaster Exercises in the Comm Center

Taken from Public Safety Communications Magazine, August 2010
Written by Bob Smith, APCO International's Director of Strategic Development.


East Coast to West Coast to Gulf Coast, hurricane season is upon us.  To prepare, many public safety agencies reviewed, evaluated and updated their disaster response plans and procedures, policies, resource lists and inventories, and personnel were quizzed on new and revised policies.

The best way to evaluate preparedness is to conduct a disaster exercise.  FEMA defines an exercise as "a focused practice activity that places the participants in a simulated situation requiring them to function in the capacity that would be expected of them in a real event.  It's purpose is to promote preparedness by testing policies and plans and training personnel."

Exercises evaluate and improve an agency's disaster response by providing an opportunity for "dry runs" or simulations related to specific disaster types.  Exercises allow all responders to proceed through actual response steps - in real time or simulation - in a controlled environment.  They also provide agencies the opportunity to monitor and evaluate their response, the response of others and the effectiveness of their tools, resources and procedures.

Disaster exercises range in format and complexity.  FEMA recognizes several formats, the most common of which are drills, tabletop and full-scale exercises.

Drills are coordinated, supervised exercises used to test a single specific operation or function.  In a drill, there's no attempt to coordinate organizations or fully activate an emergency operations center (EOC).  A drill serves to practice a single component of an agency's response plan and assist in preparations for more complex exercises.

Tabletop exercises are a facilitated analysis of an emergency situation in an informal, stress-free environment.  A tabletop exercise is designed to elicit constructive discussion as participants examine and resolve problems based on existing operational plans and identify where those plans need to be refined.  There is minimal attempt at simulaton:  Equipment isn't used, resources aren't deployed, and time pressures aren't introduced.

Full-scale exercises simulate a real event as closely as possible.  This type of exercise is designed to evaluate the operational capability of public safety systems in a highly stressful environment that simulates actual response conditions.  It requires the mobilization and movement of emergency personnel, equipment and resources and should test and evaluate most public safety functions.

A jurisdiction's public safety and emergency management agencies may conduct disaster exercises regularly, but it's not uncommon for the comm center's role to be minimized or even absent.  When the comm center is involved, the role may be nothing more than receiving the first simulated 9-1-1 call, dispatching the appropriate resources and possibly monitoring radio traffic as warranted.  This lack of participation is unfortunate.  It doesn't gauge the center's preparedness and causes a significant gap in preparedness.

So how do we address this lack of involvement?

Comm center managers must develop and maintain a quality professional relationship with local field agencies and emergency management officials.  Educating these responders and officials to the comm center's role and importance to disaster response operations before, during and after an event encourages the inclusion of the center and its personnel in exercises.

Comm center employees can play  many roles in a disaster exercise, both in and out of the radio room.  They can be used to staff EOCs or to initiate and staff an on-scene Incident Command Post (ICP).

They can also serve as evaluators to gauge and audit specific portions of on-scene operations and compare actions or inactions to exercise objectives, thus establishing a benchmarking process to gauge an exercise's success or failure.  Comm center employees require little explanation of field-level operations due to their familiarity with aspects of field-level response.

They can also monitor and evaluate on-scene radio communications and accountability policies during an exercise.

If the comm center isn't invited to participate in local disaster exercises, it falls to management to ensure policies and procedures are tested regularly.  While a jurisdiction conducts a larger disaster exercise, the comm center can incorporate facets of its own disaster preparedness.  Example:  During a large-scale, mass casualty incident-based exercise, a comm center can drill on its policies for notifying local hospitals.  For a hazmat exercise, the center can practice initiating a mass notification system simply by simulating the initiation of a notice or launching an actual system test.  Or the center can review its procedures for activating a secondary PSAP or transferring calls to a backup agency.

The bottom line:  Whether participating in a jurisdictional disaster exercise or conducting an internal drill, the comm center must establish a formal process for testing and evaluating its preparedness.  As the hub of all public safety and emergency management response, failure to ensure the comm center is prepared can cause a domino effect, hampering operations at all levels during an event.

Friday, May 2, 2014

The Four Stages of Cold-Water Immersion

Taken from On Scene, The Journal of U.S. Coast Guard Search and Rescue, Fall 2006, pg. 13
Written by RADM Alan Steinman, USPHS (Ret) and Gordon Giesbrecht, Ph.D.


Falling into cold water can be life-threating.  There are four stages of cold-water survival, and each presents the survivor with a different challenge.  The stages are: 1) cold-shock; 2) functional disability; 3) hypothermia; and 4) post-rescue collapse.  It is important to understand the risks of each stage in order to be properly prepared to survive a cold-water emergency.

Stage 1: Cold-shock (0-2 minutes): Sudden immersion in cold water causes an immediate fall in skin temperature which triggers several body reflexes.  These reflexes are collectively known as the "cold-shock" response, and they last for just the first few minutes after falling in.  The cold-shock responses are: 1) instantaneous gasping for air; 2) sudden increase in breathing rate; 3) sudden increase in heart rate; 4) sudden increase in blood pressure; and 4) dramatic decrease in breath-holding time.  If your head is underwater and the cold-shock reflex causes you to gasp and inhale (and simultaneously decreases your ability to hold your breath), you may breathe in water and drown.  This has happened often enough in the past that the Coast Guard had a term for it: "sudden drowning syndrome."  It's one reason why a personal flotation device (PFD) can be life-saving -- it helps keep your head out of the water during the first few minutes the cold-shock reflexes are active.

The increase in blood pressure and heart rate from sudden immersion into cold water can also be fatal.  These rapid changes in the cardiovascular system can trigger irregular heart beats or even cardiac arrest in susceptible individuals.  But even aside from the potential for cardiac arrest, the irregular heart beats and rapid breathing rate can be incapacitating for someone struggling to keep his head above the waves.  This is yet another good reason why a PFD can be life-saving in this situation:  it helps you stay afloat until your heart rate, blood pressure and breathing rate return to more normal levels when the cold-shock reflexes diminish.

Sudden immersion in cold water also drastically reduces your ability to hold your breath.  For the average person who can hold his breath for 60 seconds in air, breath-holding time is reduced to 20-25 seconds or less when submerged in water colder than about 50 degrees Farenheit.  This would obviously be a problem for someone trying to escape from a submerged automobile, vessel or aircraft.  Finally, the rapid breathing that occurs during the first few minutes of cold-water immersion can lead to a drop in blood levels of carbon dioxide with subsequent mental confusion or even unconsciousness; both can significantly increase your chances of drowning, particularly if you're not wearing a PFD.

Stage 2: Functional Disability (2-30 minutes):  If you survive the cold-shock reflexes after falling overboard, cold water can still affect you in other ways.  It is much harder to swim in cold water than it is in warm water.  Your muscles get cold, making it harder to use your arms and legs to stay afloat.  And cold water is a bit more vicous than is warm water, requiring you to work harder to swim or stay afloat.  Your hands get cold quickly and you lose manual dexterity and grip strength.  This can affect your ability to grasp a rescue line or life ring or even to help pull yourself back aboard your vessel.  Both swimming failuer and loss of manual dexterity can occur during the first 30 minutes after falling into cold water.  Again, a PFD would be life-saving during this period, as it would dramatically decrease your need to swim to keep your head up.

Stage 3: Hypothermia (>30 minutes):  Hypothermia is a decrease in the body's core temperature (i.e., a drop in the temperature of the body's vital organs below 95 degrees Farenheit) resulting from excessive heat loss to the cold water.  Hypothermia is not really a threat until you have been immersed in cold water for at least 30 minutes.  The body cools relatively slowly, even in extremely cold water.  When the body's temperature falls to around 86-90 degrees Farenheit, you will lose consciousness and likely drown.  But even in ice-water, this could take an hour or more to occur.  In warmer water, the timeto unconsciousness could be much longer, depending on your body size and weight (large and/or obese people survive much longer than small, skinny people), your clothing, your state of health, the sea-state, and particularly on whether you're wearing a PFD or some other means of flotation.  But without a PFD or supplemental flotation, unconsciousness in the water usually means immediate drowning.  Survival times for the average sized person wearing an insulated worksuit with inherent buoyancy (e.g., and insulated exposure coverall and medium-weight undergarments - not a survival suit) in 45 degree Farenheit water, even in heavy seas, could be as long as 5-8 hours.  For the same person wearing a survival suit, properly donned before entering the water, the survival time could be as long as 36 hours!

Stage 4: Post-Rescue Collapse (>30 minutes):  A survivor is still at significant risk even after removal from the water.  Significant levels of hypothermia can slow the body's normal defenses against a sudden drop in blood pressure.  This can occur when the survivor is removed from the water, particularly if he/she is rescued in a vertical posture and not promptly placed in a horizontal posture in the rescue vessel or aircraft.  The hypothermic heart and arteries cannot adjust fast enough to the drop in blood pressure, which may cause loss of consciousness, irregular heart beats or even cardiac arrest.  Furthermore, the body's core temperature continues to fall even after a survivor is removed from the water, a phenomenon known as "afterdrop."  If the afterdrop lowers the heart temperature too far (e.g., below avout 77 degrees Farenheit), cardiac arrest may occur.  Finally, metabolic changes in the body caused by prolonged immersion hypothermia can contribute to potentially fatal cardiovascular effects even after a survivor is rescued.  For all of the above reasons, rescuers should be particularly mindful of the ABC's of first aid, handle a hypothermic victim gently, begin gentle rewarming efforts in the rescue vehicle, and transport the survivor to a site of definitive medical care.

Drowning Doesn't Look Like Drowning


Taken from On Scene, The Journal of U.S. Coast Guard Search and Rescue, Fall 2006, pg. 14
Excerpts also taken from a blog whose writer I cannot remember the name of.


The new captain jumped from the deck, fully dressed, and sprinted through the water.  A former lifeguard, he kept his eyes on his victim as he headed straight for the couple swimming between their anchored boat and the beach.  "I think he thinks you're drowning," the husband said to his wife.  They had been splashing each other and she had screamed but now they were just standing, neck-deep on the sand bar.  "We're fine, what is he doing?" she asked, a little annoyed.  "We're fine!" the husband yelled, waving him off, but his captain kept swimming hard.  "Move!" he barked as he sprinted between the stunned owners.  Directly behind them, not even ten feet away, their nine-year-old daughter was drowning.  Safely above the surface in the arms of the captain, she burst into tears, "Daddy!"

How did this captain know - from fifty feet away - what the father couldn't recognize from just ten?  Drowning is not the violent, splashing, call for help that most people expect.  The captain was trained to recognize drowning by experts and years of experience.  The father, on the other hand, had learned what drowning looks like by watching television.  If you spend time on or near the water (hint: that's all of us) then you should make sure that you know what to look for whenever people enter the water.  Until she cried a tearful, "Daddy," she hadn't made a sound.  As a former Coast Guard rescue swimmer, I wasn't surprised at all by this story.  Drowning is almost always a deceptively quiet event.  The waving, splashing, and yelling that television prepares us to look for, is rarely seen in real life.

The Instinctive Drowning Response - so named by Francesco A. Pia, Ph.D., is what people do to avoid actual or perceived suffocation in the water.  And it does not look like most people expect.  Most people assume that a drowning person will splash, yell, and wave for help; and why wouldn't they?  That's what we see on television.  Without training, we are conditioned first to think of drowning as a violent struggle that is noisy and physical.  It is not.  To get an idea of just how quiet and undramatic from the surface drowning can be, consider this: It is the number two cause of accidental death in children, age 15 and under (just behind vehicle accidents) - of the approximately 750 children who will drown next year, about 375 of them will do so within 25 yards of a parent or other adult.  In ten percent of those drownings, the adult will actually watch them do it, having no idea it is happening.  Parents - children playing in the water make noise.  When they get quiet, you get to them and find out why.

This is not to say that a person in the water that is shouting and waving is fine and doesn't need assistance.  They are in what is known as aquatic distress.  They are not yet drowning, but realize that they are in trouble and still have the mental capacity (and lung capacity) to call for help.  Not always present before the instinctive drowning response, aquatic distress doesn't last long - but unlike true drowning, these victims can still assist in their own rescue.  They can grab lifelines, throw rings, etc.

Characteristics of the Instinctive Drowning Response:

  1. Except in rare circumstances, drowning people are physiologically unable to call out for help.  The respiratory system was designed for breathing.   Speech is the secondary, or overlaid, function.  Breathing must be fulfilled, before speech occurs.
  2. Drowning people's mouths alternately sink below and reappear above the surface of the water.  The mouths of drowning people are not above the surface of the water long enough for them to exhale, inhale, and call out for help.  When the drowning people's mouths are above the surface, they exhale and inhale quickly as their mouths start to sink below the surface of the water.
  3. Drowning people cannot wave for help.  Nature instinctively forces them to extend their arms laterally and press down on the water's surface.  Pressing down on the surface of the water, permits drowning people to leverage their bodies so they can lift their mouths out of the water to breathe.
  4. Throughout the Instinctive Drowning Response, drowning people cannot voluntarily control their arm movements.  Physicologically, drowning people who are struggling on the surface of the water cannot stop drowning and perform voluntary movements such as waving for help, moving toward a rescuer, or reaching out for a piece of rescue equipment.
  5. From beginning to end of the Instinctive Drowning Response, people's bodies remain upright in the water with no evidence of a supporting kick.  Unless rescued by a trained lifeguard, these drowning people can only struggle on the surface of the water from 20 to 60 seconds before submersion occurs.
Look for these other signs of drowning when persons are in the water:
  • Head low in the water, mouth at water level
  • Head tilted back with mouth open
  • Eyes glassy and empty, unable to focus
  • Eyes closed
  • Hair over forehead or eyes
  • Not using legs - Vertical
  • Hyperventilating or gasping
  • Trying to swim in a particular direction but not making headway
  • Trying to roll over on the back
  • Appear to be climbing an invisible ladder
So, if someone is in the water and everything looks OK - don't be too sure.  Sometimes the most common indication that someone is drowning is that they don't look like they're drowning.  They may just look like they are treading water.  One way to be sure?  Ask them, "Are you alright?"  If they can answer at all - they probably are.  If they return a blank stare, you may have less than 30 seconds to get to them.

http://youtu.be/X1mVcSUttx4

http://youtu.be/RE8ly9BsU_M